Right then, Twilight

Y’all may remember that a few weeks back we at the Murkworks had us a Sparkly Evening of Vampire Sparklyness: a group viewing of Twilight. I got asked by userinfomarzipan_pig if I would review the movie. So this is me, doing that!

Short form, honestly: not as godawful as I was expecting. It is not a good movie by any stretch of the imagination, but it did have occasional okay moments in it.

Going in, even though I haven’t actually read the book, I nonetheless had an overview idea of what would happen. So nothing was really a surprise, which I grant may have lost me something in the movie viewing experience. My attention was caught therefore not by the events playing out, but rather how those events were depicted.

For example, the Big Reveal where Edward makes with showing Bella the sparkling: not nearly as visually striking as it should have been. Edward looked like he had a flashlight on in his shirt pocket, and the beam was reflecting off his chest. Not at all what I was expecting–though I’ll also grant that if they’d gone more obviously Sparkly it would have looked even cheesier, so hey.

Not much better implementation of Edward’s speed, either. Watching him scramble up a tree with Bella clinging to his back was making us all go “wait, vampires are howler monkeys?”

But of course the main point of the story is the relationship between Bella and Edward. Which is in turn of course the whole issue I have with the story to begin with: I just don’t buy it. I will freely admit I am biased from my Joss Whedon fandom here, but with Buffy and Angel, I’ve already had a much more intense and dangerous relationship between a teenage girl and a vampire a lot older than she is. With Angel, especially in Season 2 of Buffy, you believe that this guy can and will at the slightest provocation rip Buffy’s throat out. Not so with Edward. Young Mr. Pattinson is very pretty, I’ll give him that, but I never believed that his character was actually dangerous to Bella at any point. It didn’t help either that half the time the boy looked more constipated than dazzling, too.

I did say that the movie had a couple of halfway okay bits, and I’ll stand by that. Cheesy though it might have been, I kind of liked Vampire Baseball after userinfosolarbird pointed out that it was one of the more unusual things we’ve seen vampires do in, well, anything. There’s also a good bit where Edward casually leaps off of something and Bella says testily to him, “Can you at least try to act human? I’ve got neighbors!” It’s one of the few places in the movie where Bella shows a bit of spark, not to mention the world beyond just her and Edward.

All in all it’s a fun movie to watch in a group that isn’t taking it seriously, especially if there’s MSTing to be done. It does fall into that range of badness that makes it excellent for the Mystery Science treatment.

But I still ain’t reading the book. ;)

Published by

Angela Korra'ti

As Angela Highland, Angela is the writer of the Rebels of Adalonia epic fantasy series with Carina Press. As Angela Korra'ti, she writes the Free Court of Seattle urban fantasy series. She's also an amateur musician and devoted fan of Newfoundland and Quebecois traditional music.